In industrial production, bar stock serves as an important raw material and directly affects the performance and quality of subsequent products. Titanium alloys and superalloys are costly and scarce resources. To reduce enterprise costs and actively meet national requirements for material conservation, consumption reduction and energy saving, improving the utilization rate of raw materials has become increasingly important. Re-inspection of bar stock is a critical step to guarantee its quality, among which the re-inspection of mechanical properties and metallographic microstructure is essential. However, the conventional re-inspection process suffers from large material consumption. This paper conducts an in-depth study on the feasibility and practical application of shared sampling for various re-inspection items of bar stock, including mechanical properties (such as tensile properties, impact properties and hardness) and metallographic microstructure (grain size, non-metallic inclusions, microstructures, etc.). By discussing relevant theories, test methods, data processing and analysis as well as practical cases, this work aims to provide scientific basis and practical guidance for improving the efficiency of bar stock re-inspection, reducing costs and ensuring product quality.
In recent years, with the rapid development of China’s aviation industry, the consumption of raw materials such as superalloys GH4169, GH738, GH141, titanium alloys TC11, TC4 and structural steel A‑100 has increased sharply. Consequently, the supply of bar stock falls short of demand, resulting in a tight supply of bar stock for production. It is urgent to realize energy and material conservation and improve the utilization rate of bar stock in the re‑inspection stage. Bar stock may suffer property changes affected by various factors during production, transportation and storage. Therefore, strict re‑inspection is essential to guarantee product quality. In conventional re‑inspection of bar stock, mechanical property testing and metallographic examination are usually carried out separately. This mode not only consumes abundant materials, time and labor costs, but also may lead to result deviation due to sampling randomness. This paper discusses the method and feasibility of shared sampling for mechanical property and metallographic re‑inspection items, which is of great significance for improving re‑inspection efficiency, reducing costs and enhancing the stability of product quality.
As the starting material for component manufacturing, the quality of bar stock directly determines the performance and reliability of final products. Especially in the quality‑oriented aviation industry, bar stock quality must be reliable, compliant, stable, effective, accurate and traceable. Re‑inspection can timely detect defects, abnormal properties and other problems in bar stock, preventing the use of unqualified bar stock in production so as to ensure product quality and reduce scrap rate and after‑sales issues. For instance, in aero‑engine manufacturing, if the adopted bar stock has insufficient stress rupture property or inhomogeneous metallographic microstructure, disk‑shaft fracture may occur during engine operation, which may even cause catastrophic air accidents.
Stringent standards and specifications on bar stock quality are stipulated in different industries and fields. Re‑inspection of bar stock is a necessary means to verify its compliance with relevant standards. In the aerospace sector, extremely high requirements are imposed on indicators such as mechanical properties and metallographic microstructure of bar stock. Precise re‑inspection is mandatory to ensure the material meets design and service requirements for safe and reliable operation of aircraft.
When quality failures occur in service, tracing and analyzing re‑inspection data of bar stock helps identify the root cause and judge whether the failure originates from inherent quality defects of the bar stock. This enables enterprises to adopt targeted improvement measures, elevate the level of product quality control, and provides critical data support for the corporate quality traceability system.
The tensile test is one of the fundamental tests for measuring mechanical properties of bar stock. It can obtain key indicators including tensile strength, yield strength, percentage elongation after fracture and reduction of area. These indicators reflect the mechanical behavior and deformation capacity of bar stock under tensile load, and are important for evaluating its strength and ductility.
For tensile tests, standard specimens shall be prepared in accordance with relevant standards such as GB/T 228.1‑2021 Metallic materials — Tensile testing — Part 1: Method of test at room temperature. The specimen is mounted on a tensile testing machine, and tensile load is applied at a specified rate. The force‑displacement curve during tension is recorded, and various mechanical property indicators are calculated through curve analysis.
The impact test is mainly used to determine the impact toughness of bar stock, i.e., the capacity of the material to resist fracture under impact load. Impact toughness is an important indicator for characterizing material performance under dynamic loads. For components subjected to impact loads (e.g., automotive suspension systems and engineering machinery structural parts), the impact toughness of bar stock directly affects service life and safety.
Common impact test methods include Charpy V‑notch and Charpy U‑notch impact tests. During testing, the notched specimen is placed on the supports of an impact tester, and a pendulum strikes the specimen. The energy absorbed upon fracture is recorded as impact energy, by which the impact toughness is evaluated. Relevant standards such as GB/T 229‑2020 Metallic materials — Charpy pendulum impact test specify the equipment, specimen preparation and test procedures in detail.
Hardness refers to the ability of a material to resist local deformation, especially plastic deformation, indentation or scratching. Hardness testing is a simple and rapid method for mechanical property inspection. Hardness values can be used to indirectly assess strength, wear resistance and other properties of materials. Common hardness testing methods include Brinell, Rockwell and Vickers hardness tests. Each method has its own scope of application, advantages and limitations. The appropriate method shall be selected according to the material grade and hardness range of bar stock. Standards including GB/T 231.1‑2018 Metallic materials — Brinell hardness test — Part 1: Test method regulate these hardness test procedures.
Grain size describes the size of grains in metallic materials and exerts a remarkable influence on mechanical properties of bar stock. Generally speaking, finer grains bring higher strength, toughness and ductility. Grain size measurement is an important metallographic re‑inspection item. Widely adopted methods include the comparison method, area method and intercept method.
The comparison method determines grain size grade by comparing the microstructure of the specimen with standard grain size charts. The area method calculates grain size by counting grains within a known area. The intercept method evaluates grain size by counting the intersections between test lines and grain boundaries. GB/T 6394‑2017 Methods for estimating the average grain size of metals specifies the test methods and criteria for grain size measurement.
Non‑metallic inclusions are various non‑metallic substances existing in metals, such as oxides, sulfides and nitrides. Such inclusions break the continuity of the metallic matrix and degrade mechanical properties, especially toughness, fatigue strength and corrosion resistance. Therefore, non‑metallic inclusion rating is a key part of metallographic re‑inspection.
Non‑metallic inclusion rating mainly involves analysis of inclusion type, quantity, size and distribution. In accordance with standards such as GB/T 10561‑2023 Steel — Determination of content of non‑metallic inclusions — Micrographic method using standard diagrams, the specimen is observed under a microscope, and inclusions are classified and graded by comparison with standard rating charts to assess their adverse effects on bar stock quality.
Microstructure analysis observes the morphology, fraction and distribution of structural constituents inside bar stock, such as pearlite, ferrite, martensite and bainite. Different microstructures possess distinct performance characteristics. Microstructure analysis reveals the effects of processing routes and heat treatment states on microstructure and properties, and verifies whether the bar stock meets the specified structural requirements.
Microstructure analysis is usually performed by optical microscope or electron microscope. For complex microstructures, supplementary characterization techniques (e.g., electron backscatter diffraction, EBSD) are adopted for in‑depth investigation to accurately identify structural types and features.
From the perspective of materials science, there is an inherent close correlation between mechanical properties and metallographic microstructure of bar stock. Microstructure determines the fundamental properties of the material, while mechanical properties are the macroscopic manifestation of microstructure under loading. For example, fine grains improve strength and toughness, whereas coarse grains degrade material performance; non‑metallic inclusions impair mechanical properties, with pronounced impacts on toughness and fatigue performance. Hence, re‑inspection of mechanical properties and metallographic features on the same bar stock enables mutual verification and complementary results, reflecting the quality status of bar stock from different perspectives, which is theoretically feasible.
In practical re‑inspection, mechanical testing and metallographic examination are compatible to a certain extent. For instance, after tensile or impact tests, although specimens are deformed or fractured, partial material can be cut from them for metallographic examination. Alternatively, surplus material of the same heat treatment state can be sampled for mechanical testing after metallographic inspection. Hardness testing causes minor damage to specimens and generally does not interfere with subsequent metallographic observation. Meanwhile, specimen preparation procedures for metallography (sampling, mounting, grinding, polishing, etching, etc.) do not significantly alter the mechanical properties of bar stock, supporting operability of shared sampling re‑inspection.
Shared sampling for mechanical and metallographic re‑inspection can substantially reduce inspection costs, especially under the background of rising raw material prices and resource shortage. On the one hand, the number and frequency of sampling are reduced, cutting material consumption. On the other hand, repeated specimen preparation and testing are avoided, saving time and labor costs. Moreover, conducting both re‑inspection items on the same bar stock reduces result deviation caused by sampling difference, improving the accuracy and reliability of test data and enhancing the overall efficiency and quality of re‑inspection work.
A reasonable sampling scheme is critical for ensuring result accuracy in shared sampling re‑inspection. First, sampling position and quantity are determined according to bar stock specification, production batch and processing technology. Samples shall generally be taken from different sections (head, middle and tail) of the bar to guarantee representativeness for the whole bar. For mechanical tests and metallographic examination, specimens of different sizes and shapes can be cut from the same sampling location, with attention paid to avoid mutual interference. For example, when preparing tensile specimens that meet standard dimensions, material near the fracture surface or other regions of the tensile specimen can be reserved for metallographic sampling. If the standard requires transverse data for both mechanical and metallographic tests, transverse slices can be cut first. Metallographic examination is carried out on the slice, and then sub‑specimens are cut from the same slice for mechanical property testing.
To realize efficient shared sampling re‑inspection, the test workflow should be optimized. Non‑destructive or slightly destructive tests (e.g., hardness testing, low‑magnification metallographic observation) are arranged first, followed by destructive mechanical tests such as tensile and impact tests. After mechanical tests are completed, metallographic specimens are promptly cut from the tested samples and processed following standard metallographic preparation procedures including mounting, grinding, polishing and etching, before high‑magnification metallographic observation and analysis. Operating conditions and parameters in each step shall be strictly controlled throughout the whole process to secure test accuracy and repeatability.
Comprehensive processing and analysis of mechanical and metallographic data obtained from shared sampling are essential. Establishing correlations between the two categories of data enables a more comprehensive and in‑depth evaluation of bar stock quality. For example, correlation analysis can be performed between metallographic parameters (grain size, non‑metallic inclusion rating, etc.) and mechanical indicators (tensile strength, impact toughness, etc.) to identify inherent relationships and variation rules. When abnormal mechanical properties are detected, metallographic results can help judge whether the anomaly originates from coarse grains, excessive inclusions or other structural defects. Conversely, abnormal metallographic features can be verified by mechanical testing to quantify their influence on practical service performance. This integrated data analysis method provides valuable information for bar stock quality assessment and improvement.
Raw materials of superalloys including GH4169, GH141 and GH698
For superalloys such as GH141 (standards: XXX16, XX712), GH4169 (standards: XXXX31, XXXX13, XXX000D, XXX40A), GH698 (standards: XXX2004, XX285‑84, etc.) and GH99 (standards: XX.17, XXX126B‑0, etc.), the following practice is adopted: for raw materials where transverse/longitudinal requirements are not specified in standards, historical re‑inspection data are reviewed. If longitudinal mechanical property data are far above standard limits and all available transverse mechanical data meet specifications, only transverse 20 mm test slices are cut, and all other test items share the same slice for mechanical and metallographic testing. From January to December 2024, a total of 592 batches of superalloys adopted this material‑saving scheme, saving 10581.21 kg of raw materials worth 3.2587 million RMB, as shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1 Material saving of shared sampling for physical and chemical test items of superalloys
Titanium alloys such as TC11, TC4 and TC21
For titanium alloys including TC4 (standards: XXX342‑2004, XXX18A‑2008, XXX94A‑2008, etc.), TC11 (standards: XXX47‑2004, XXX320‑2007, XXX218A, etc.), TC21 (standards: XXX3‑001, XXX516) and TC4‑DT (standards: XXX1511, XXX03‑002), the following method is applied: for raw materials without transverse/longitudinal requirements specified in standards, historical re‑inspection data are reviewed. If the longitudinal mechanical property data are considerably higher than the specification limits and the available transverse mechanical test data all meet the requirements, only 20 mm‑thick transverse test slices are prepared for physical and chemical inspection. Sampling is switched from longitudinal to transverse 20 mm slices, and all other test items adopt the shared‑sampling material‑saving scheme. In 2024, a total of 557 batches of titanium alloys and aluminum alloys implemented this material‑saving measure, saving 6466.79 kg of raw materials with a value of 2.0325 million RMB, as shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2 Material saving of shared sampling for physical and chemical test items of titanium alloys and aluminum alloys
It can be seen from the above cases that shared sampling re‑inspection combining mechanical property testing and metallographic examination possesses important application value in practical production. This method can not only effectively identify quality defects of bar stock, but also reveal the root causes of quality issues through comprehensive analysis of two types of test data, providing support for enterprises to formulate targeted improvement measures. Meanwhile, the implementation of shared sampling re‑inspection requires enterprises to be equipped with complete test equipment, professional technicians and a rigorous quality control system to guarantee the accuracy and reliability of test results.
Shared sampling for mechanical property and metallographic re‑inspection during bar stock re‑inspection is theoretically feasible, compatible in test methods, and delivers prominent advantages in cost reduction and efficiency improvement. Rational sampling scheme design, optimized test workflow and standardized data processing and analysis enable effective shared sampling re‑inspection, which supplies comprehensive and reliable data for accurate quality evaluation of bar stock. In practical application, this method helps enterprises detect bar stock quality problems in a timely manner, trace the root causes and carry out targeted improvements, so as to improve product quality, cut production costs and strengthen the market competitiveness of enterprises.
With the continuous development of materials science and testing technologies, the testing methods for mechanical properties and metallographic microstructure in bar stock re‑inspection will become more advanced, precise and efficient. For example, the application of non‑destructive testing technology in mechanical and metallographic inspection will keep expanding, and full‑coverage and real‑time monitoring of internal quality of bar stock is expected to be realized. The advancement of microanalysis techniques (such as high‑resolution electron microscopy and three‑dimensional imaging technology) will provide more detailed and accurate information for metallographic analysis, which helps further reveal the intrinsic relationship between mechanical properties and metallographic microstructure. In addition, artificial intelligence and big data for test data processing and analysis will become an important development trend. Intelligent quality evaluation models can be established to realize rapid and accurate judgment on bar stock quality, delivering smarter quality control solutions for bar stock manufacturers and users.